Reporting a vulnerability

How to report a security problem privately, and what happens next

  1. Report it privately
  2. What to include
  3. What happens next
  4. Scope

Report it privately

AnsibleForms holds credentials and vault tokens, so never report a security problem in a public issue:

  1. Open Report a vulnerability: a private advisory only the maintainers see.
  2. If that page is not available to you, open a normal issue that says only that you have a security report and asks for a private channel: no details, no reproducer, no version numbers. A maintainer opens a private advisory and invites you to it.

The full policy is the repository’s SECURITY.md.


What to include

The more of this a report gives, the faster it is fixed:

  • What an attacker gains: another user’s data, a playbook they may not run, the host, or admin rights.
  • The version, and how it is deployed: Docker, Kubernetes, or installed natively.
  • A reproducer, or the request that triggers it.
  • Whether it needs a signed-in user, and with which role options.

What happens next

A report goes through the same private advisory from the first message to the publication:

Step What you get
Acknowledgement Confirmation that the report arrived, and whether it reproduces
Accepted A fix in the next release of every supported version, and a published advisory that credits you, unless you would rather not be named
Declined The reasoning, usually that the behaviour needs a permission the reporter already had

Once the fix is released, the advisory is published and appears in Security advisories.


Scope

The policy draws the line where the role model draws it:

In scope Out of scope
Anything a signed-in user can reach beyond what their role grants Findings that need the admin account to be compromised already: an admin running any playbook is the product
Anything reachable without signing in Scanner reports with no demonstrated impact
Stored credentials becoming readable, or written to a log  
Injection into the shell, the database or the browser